Belief and Knowledge- The Origins
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
There are two different types of people in the world. Those who want to know and those who want to believe. Friedrich Nietzsche
I am interested in belief and knowledge as ideas.
Having read a brief amount of the history of knowledge as "justified true belief" including the Gettier problem, I have some major reservations about modern philosophical discussion about the idea of belief. My reservations stem from the cultural perspective of division or duality practised by science and society.
Having read a brief amount of the history of knowledge as "justified true belief" including the Gettier problem, I have some major reservations about modern philosophical discussion about the idea of belief. My reservations stem from the cultural perspective of division or duality practised by science and society.
As with all philosophical ideas approached from an Oneness
perspective (Monistic ideaism) my reservations are entirely understandable. The
root of the idea of belief is associated with knowledge (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descriptive_knowledge).
Belief and knowledge are opposites in the conceptual sense.
I can believe without knowing. Or I can know without believing. To mix the two
concepts seems contradictory to me.
First I disagree with the use of belief to be a requirement
for knowledge. In its purest sense knowledge from my Oneness perspective is
information gained by a person through; an event of experience, experimentation, intuition, study or meditation. The need for knowledge, correct or otherwise is not contingent upon
belief.
Second the idea of truth (True), viewed from my Oneness
Theory (OT) perspective is not a measurable concept in an as of itself and is
not a necessary component of belief.
Third, justification is a state rather than an idea when
viewed from my OT perspective and as such cannot have any part in the
understanding or explanation of belief. Justification implies judgment to
achieve a state of justification.
So to the nitty gritty. What then is belief (Philosophically
speaking)?
From my OT perspective I would define the concept of belief
as “a state of mind not dependent upon information.”
Or to define the concept in more positive terms, a state of
mind that requires freedom of thought to know something other than by; events
of experience, experimentation, intuition, study or meditation..
That is an idea in and of itself.
What then is knowledge?
From my OT perspective I would define the concept of knowledge
as the accumulation of information gained by a person through; an event of
experience, experimentation, intuition, free meditation or study
Disclaimer:
- Mileage may vary.
- I am responsible for what I write. I am not reponsible for how it is understood.
© Copyright Geoff Ogilvie 2011-2025
No comments:
Post a Comment